Is the Black Church Dead ?

So i just got done reading this article which recently posted at politicsdaily.com, entitled   “is the black church dead ?”  This was a very insightful document with regard to the beginnings of generations of black Christians who expressed their frustrations and need for social justice and change in a society which was by far and wide segregated and divided even among religious lines. The Author brought in several other writers’ perspectives: in their view, many Black churches have forgotten about the principles and causes for which the black Church stood within the civil rights movement wherein preachers like Dr. king spoke on issues affecting the black community and rallying folks to stand up for what was just and true.

Some of the most interesting points that I found are as follows:

With regard to the black mega churches, some writers argue that some preach a money-centered “prosperity gospel” that traditional African American clergy consider betrayal of their faith’s legacy of sacrifice and social justice…

During similar discussions on this topic, participants lamented that they had found growing conservatism and anti-intellectualism in the black church…

And lastly, Eddie Glaude, Jr., a young  African American Professor of religion at Princeton states: “upwardly mobile blacks are continuing the process of assimilation and are therefore attending traditionally white churches, while African –Americans of all classes are drawn to mega churches led by white pastors such as Joel Osteen and Rick Warren. Entrepreneurial black clergy including bishop long and creflo dollar are also trying to create their own mega church phenomena, and are building on the legacy of flash-and-cash African American pastors of the past like reverend Ike and Prophet Jones”

I want to review the stated information in light of the Church of Christ as we know it today. The whole black church and white church seems to be getting better in terms of the number of mixed congregations we have—this should go without saying, because Christ died for the Church as a whole, and so we should be able to worship together as a whole—I understand that sometimes cultures are variant and folks might feel comfortable in going to a predominantly white or black Church, however, that should be the exception to the rule(based on culture) and not the rule itself (that is to have a white or a black church) .

Secondly, I believe that there is still a sort of anti-intellectualism encouraged within our churches (black or white).  Instead of seeking to build on knowledge, many seek to attain preaching school Certificates, to preach the same old sermons and continue the same old methods of evangelism, when our world has changed and is changing so very rapidly. In some cases, we have developed an attitude that says, we have the Truth, so we want the world to come to us and if they don’t, we will shake off the dust from our feet. Many in the Church see no need for apologetics; if they encounter atheists or folks’ who don’t believe in the Bible, some have actually said they won’t waste their time to try to minister to them or teach them the truth.

With regard to black Churches of Christ, I still see the struggle with regard to leadership modules. Many think they own the Church or should be the sole leader; you see many downplay the need for Elders or more transparency within the leadership itself. It’s not that they have mega churches in reality, but intellectually some retain the mega church mentality. they want to be “the minister” and rule “their ministry”. as a reaction against many white churches having elders, they see their role as African american preachers necessitating power, which should not be quenched by elders who employ docile preachers to operate through a contractual agreement. These are my considerations and thoughts thus far. Feel free to engage with this discussion…


2 Comments on “Is the Black Church Dead ?”

  1. Kaara says:

    I agree with your 3 main points about the COC and the black churches. I don’t think we are really doing a good job of integration. Perhaps there are more Blacks worshiping at white churches, thus “integrating” those churches. But I certainly do not see the reverse. I hardly see whites visiting or worshiping with black congregations. Additionally, I have noticed that we can have 10 churches in the same city and none of these churches fellowship with each other. We do not support the ladies day at the white congregations but we send a bus to drive 2 hours away to the black congregations…and it applies both ways. Why is that? It almost seems that for true “integration” to take place the Blacks must suppress their “culture” and subscribe to the low-key, mellow culture of the white churches. I have no problems personally worshiping at either…My preference is the be with people who are striving to live right and do right according to God’s word. And to be around people who are real, and keep it real. People who are not afraid to challenge mainstream thinking…

    Which brings me to my next point. Or should I say your next point…When I went home to Trinidad in January, I was talking with a brother and he was suggesting that when people “get an education” its like they get too educated and “leave the truth they once knew.” I have a hard time believing that education causes people to leave the truth seeing that I am currently surrounded by some very educated black people! BUT, I would say this, school does challenge your thinking, and enhances your critical thinking skills. However, we are often discouraged to apply those very same critical thinking skills when it comes to studying the doctrine. We are thought to memorize and regurgitate, but not analyze, and view all possibilities. And OMG if you dear say something contrary to what is being postulated, because then you are labeled as a liberal. We who have been indoctrinated are afraid to think…Some of us have the understanding to think critically, but we are afraid that if we do, we may not like what we find…

    And of course, the leadership in the black church is such a contrast with the white congregations. We need our black preachers to submit to God’s word on leadership for His church…Because then it becomes about you and not about Him.

  2. pisteuo says:

    Thanks for adding some insight. I think that my idea with regard to “integration” is a tad off as they say. it is one of those things that i maybe try to think of as being too progressive, in order to have a more positive as oppose to negative thought process, with regard to the whole race issue. however, only the Truth can set us free, so i would agree with you that though some integration is apparent, alot of Churches, if not above 50% are majority white or majority black. i hope this changes, as we understand ourselves more in light of the word and not try to funnel the word through our cultural and personal lenses.


Leave a comment